Justia District of Columbia Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries

An off-duty police officer in the District of Columbia shot and seriously injured a man outside a residence in Maryland after suspecting an attempted vehicle break-in. The officer did not call 911 as trained, confronted the individual, and used deadly force, although no weapon or evidence of crime was found on the victim. Following internal reviews, the police department sought to terminate the officer. His union invoked arbitration, as allowed by the collective bargaining agreement.An arbitrator determined that the officer’s conduct was reckless, violated departmental policies, and met the definition of reckless endangerment under Maryland law. However, the arbitrator concluded that termination was not warranted and reduced the discipline to a 45-day suspension, referencing a prior similar case involving another officer. The District of Columbia Public Employee Relations Board (PERB) sustained this sanction. The Superior Court of the District of Columbia affirmed PERB’s decision. On a prior appeal, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals remanded the case, directing PERB to further explain its reasoning regarding whether the arbitral award was contrary to law or public policy.After PERB again upheld the arbitrator’s decision on remand and the Superior Court affirmed, the case returned to the District of Columbia Court of Appeals. The court reviewed whether the arbitral award was “on its face contrary to law and public policy.” The court held that the award was not contrary to law because the arbitrator did not purport to apply and misapply the Douglas factors, nor was the penalty so disproportionate as to be illegal. The court further held that the award was not contrary to public policy, noting the absence of a statutory or regulatory mandate requiring termination under these circumstances and emphasizing the narrow grounds for overturning arbitral awards on public policy. The court affirmed the judgment upholding PERB’s decision. View "District of Columbia Metropolitan Police Dep't v. District of Columbia Public Employee Relations Board" on Justia Law